DentonImages.com Home Page
Start your online shopping here and help support our site: Amazon, B&H Photo Video, Adorama, 
Featured...
• Compare DSLR's
• ISO Compare
• Memory Card Tests
• Rate & Review
• Price Watch
• Firmware Updates
• About Nikon Lenses
• DLSR Glossary
• Full Disclosure
• Support Us
Gear Guides...
• Tripods and Support
• DSLR
• Lenses
• Macro
• Flash Photography
• Studio Lighting
• Panoramic
• Bags and Cases
Latest Reviews...
• Canon EOS 60D Review – Intro & Specs
• Canon EOS 60D Review - Handling
• Canon EOS 60D Review - ISO Samples
• Canon EOS 60D Review - Conclusion & Recommendations
• Canon EOS 60D Review - Performance
• More...
News / Rumors...
• News
• Rumors
• Nikon
• Canon
• Sony
• More...
Latest Articles...
• Choosing A Monopod
• Nikon and Canon in 2011 Part 2: Prosumer DSLR’s
• Nikon and Canon in 2011 Part 1: Pro DSLR's
• Uses For Arca Multipurpose Rails
• Arca Style Lever Clamps
• More...
Gear Database...
• DSLR Info
• Lens Info
• Nikon
• Canon
• Sony
• More...
Rate...
• Best DSLR's
• Best Retailers
• Best Reviewers
• Best Communities
• Best News Sites
• More...
What's New...
• Canon EOS 1D Mark V Rumor: Mid September
• Nikon D800 Rumor: Bryan Peterson Says September
• Nikon D4 Rumor: Bryan Peterson Says September
• Canon EOS 3D Rumor: 2012
• More...
Links...
Facebook
(DentonImages)
Facebook
(Steve Denton)
Site Update Blog
Flickr
Twitter





Site Updated: 7/13/11
Site Index
Archive

1427 RSS Readers
In The Last Day

Review: Memory Card Performance Tests

Posted 9/15/08 by
Last Updated: 11/30/99
 Post to Facebook
 Post to Twitter

Email Page | Comments
 This article is part of the following Gear Guide(s): 
 DSLR 

In This Article:

Related Articles:

   Why Card Performance Matters
   Testing In-Camera Card Performance
   Compact Flash (CF) Card Performance Results
   Secure Digital (SD) Card Performance Results
   Choosing the Right Memory Card.
   Protecting Your Photos.
   Nikon D300 Memory Card Test.
   Nikon D200 Memory Card Test.

Why Card Performance Matters

There are 4 primary aspects to be considered when choosing a memory card:
  1. Reliability – this is discussed extensively in our Choosing the Right Memory Card, and Protecting your Data article.
  2. How long it takes to upload your pictures to your computer – manufacturers claim read/write speeds, which they obtain under optimum conditions using the fastest card readers and computers, individual results may vary significantly depending on the computer and reader used.
  3. Card size, making sure you have enough to cover your shooting needs, and one big card verses multiple small cards is also discussed in our Choosing the Right Memory Card, and Protecting your Data article.
  4. How the card performs in the camera. For the landscape shooter or other users that carefully compose each shot, card speed is unimportant. For anyone that shoots action, card speed can be critical.

This section focuses on how different cards perform in different bodies.

Testing In-Camera Card Performance

All modern DSLR's have onboard buffers – basically RAM memory, just like your computer. When pictures are taken they are written directly to the buffer, the camera applies any processing (sharpening, noise reduction, saturation etc), and then the image is written to the memory card. Memory cards are much slower than the buffer, so if you are shooting at a high frame rate, you will more than likely fill the buffer at some point. The camera continues to move the images from the buffer to the memory card as quickly as it can, even while you are shooting. In the real world, how important is the in-camera card speed? Twenty years ago, I was shooting a Formula 1 race at Silverstone in England with Nikon F Photomic's and manual focus lenses. I'd pre-focus the lens on a certain part of the corner, and shoot cars as they went through. A second or so later, I'd have wound onto the next frame, steadied the camera and would be ready for the next car (and possibly missed a car or two that passed in the mean time). If a car slid mid corner, chances are I'd miss it. If it crashed, it would take a second or so to refocus manually and you'd miss some of the action. With today's DSLR's with their advanced autofocus systems, the camera's can easily track cars and refocus on the next car in a split second, and the ability to shoot high frame rates significantly increases your chance of getting that shot of the car sliding, the overtaking maneuver, sparks flying from under the car and so on.

While you are unlikely to just hold down the shutter and keep shooting for extended periods, taking a burst of 6 shots, followed a few seconds later by an 9 shot burst, then another burst shortly afterwards is not uncommon when there is a lot of action. If you are shooting RAW, your camera probably gives you less than 20 shots before the buffer fills. By the third, fourth or fifth burst, your buffer will likely fill. This is where card speed comes into play – when the buffer fills, and it invariably will, what becomes important is (a) what kind of frame rate you can expect while the buffer is full, and (b) how long it takes the camera to empty the buffer to the card. This is what we've set out to test in this article.

Compact Flash (CF) Card Performance Results

The following cards were tested:

The SanDisk Ducati, Sandisk Extreme III and Lexar 300x are all UDMA cards. UDMA (Ultra Direct Memory Access) is an interface that allows a higher transfer rate of date to the camera body, providing the body supports the UDMA interface. UDMA cards will work in non-UDMA cameras (like the Nikon D200), although they won't be able to take advantage of the UDMA feature. Cameras like the Nikon D300 that supports the UDMA interface can still use non-UDMA cards.

The following table highlights the summary of results of these cards with different bodies:

Card Card Size Actual Size* Card Speed** UDMA Nikon D300*** Nikon D200***
SanDisk Ducati 8 GB 7.62 GB 45 MB/s Yes 27.62 MB/sec
2.09 fps
6.87 sec
More
9.69 MB/sec
0.68 fps
29.82 sec
More
SanDisk Extreme IV 8 GB 7.62 GB 40 MB/s Yes 27.13 MB/sec
2.08 fps
7.17 sec
More
9.57 MB/sec
0.67 fps
30.29 sec
More
Lexar Professional 300x 8 GB 7.45 GB 45 MB/s Yes 22.83 MB/sec
2.01 fps
9.28 sec
More
8.54 MB/sec
0.58 fps
35.21 sec
More
SanDisk Extreme III 8 GB 7.62 GB 20 MB/s No 10.90 MB/sec
0.80 fps
18.89 sec
More
7.74 MB/sec
0.51 fps
37.95 sec
More
SanDisk Ultra II 8 GB 7.62 GB 15 MB/s No 5.86 MB/sec
0.33 fps
34.82 sec
More
5.31 MB/sec
0.35 fps
56.98 sec
More

* The actual available space on the card after formatting.
** Card write speed as claimed by the manufacturer.
*** The MB/sec number is the maximum measured Megabytes per Second transfer rate from camera to card, the fps number is the maximum number of frames per second achieved with a full buffer shooting RAW, and the time in seconds is how long it took to clear a full buffer after shooting stopped. Click on the link in the table for full details and explanation.

As expected, the UDMA cards are faster than the non-UDMA. The SanDisk Ducati was the fastest card in just about every test. Despite being rated at the same speed as the SanDisk Ducati, the Lexar 300x was actually slower than the 266x Sandisk Extreme IV in most cases. All the cards are rated at 8Gb, however the Lexar also had almost 200MB less space available for images than the SanDisks.

To see the full report and detailed results for a specific body, please click a link below:

Nikon D300
Nikon D200

Secure Digital (SD) Card Performance Results

Coming Soon for the Nikon D90.
 This article is part of the following Gear Guide(s): 
 DSLR 


If you found this page helpful, please Link to it, or Email This Page to a friend.

 RSS Feeds

How to Link to this Page

To link to this page from your website, simply cut and paste the following code to your web page:

This will display on your web site as:

Memory Card Performance Tests Review at DentonImages.com

Nikon D3100: $599.95
Canon T3 1100D: $595.00
Sony Cyber-shot H55: $199.00
More DSLRs...

Nikon 85mm: $489.95
Canon 70-200mm: $2,449.95
Sony 30mm: $199.00
More Lenses...



Home | DSLR News | Reviews | Articles | Blog | Gear Guides | About |